[LTR] Add Goldberry, River-Daughter (#10524)

* Added Goldberry

* Slight optimizaztion

* Happy Path Test

* More unhappy tests

* Sanity check for Goldberry's counter choices

* Updated player.getMultiAmount to support individual constraints

* Some cleanup

Also modified ResourcefulDefense to use new multi amount api

* Updated logging

* Added hint for number of counters

* Fixed issue with Resourceful Defense

* Improvements to defaults

Default list will properly make sure to stay within individual maximums
If a player is asked for a choice that isn't actually a choice because each choice's min and max are equal, instead the default response is immediately returned. This helps with situations like moving a counter off of Goldberry when she only has one counter on her.

* -1/-1 Counter test

* Fixed issue with -1/-1 counters

* Adjusted dialog to properly enforce constraints

Mage.Client/src/main/java/mage/client/dialog/PickMultiNumberDialog.java

@@ -1,6 +1,8 @@
 package mage.client.dialog;
 
 import mage.constants.ColoredManaSymbol;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
+
 import org.mage.card.arcane.ManaSymbols;
 
 import javax.swing.*;
@@ -25,7 +27,7 @@ public class PickMultiNumberDialog extends MageDialog {
         this.setModal(true);
     }
 
-    public void showDialog(List<String> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+    public void showDialog(List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
         this.header.setText((String) options.get("header"));
         this.header.setHorizontalAlignment(SwingConstants.CENTER);
         this.setTitle((String) options.get("title"));
@@ -51,7 +53,7 @@ public class PickMultiNumberDialog extends MageDialog {
 
             // mana mode
             String manaText = null;
-            String input = messages.get(i);
+            String input = messages.get(i).message;
             switch (input) {
                 case "W":
                     manaText = ColoredManaSymbol.W.getColorHtmlName();
@@ -87,13 +89,13 @@ public class PickMultiNumberDialog extends MageDialog {
             labelList.add(label);
 
             JSpinner spinner = new JSpinner();
-            spinner.setModel(new SpinnerNumberModel(0, 0, max, 1));
+            spinner.setModel(new SpinnerNumberModel(0, messages.get(i).min, messages.get(i).max, 1));
             spinnerC.weightx = 0.5;
             spinnerC.gridx = 1;
             spinnerC.gridy = i;
             spinnerC.ipadx = 20;
             spinner.addChangeListener(e -> {
-                updateControls(min, max);
+                updateControls(min, max, messages);
             });
             jPanel1.add(spinner, spinnerC);
             spinnerList.add(spinner);
@@ -101,20 +103,28 @@ public class PickMultiNumberDialog extends MageDialog {
         this.counterText.setText("0 out of 0");
         this.counterText.setHorizontalAlignment(SwingConstants.CENTER);
 
-        updateControls(min, max);
+        updateControls(min, max, messages);
 
         this.pack();
         this.makeWindowCentered();
         this.setVisible(true);
     }
 
-    private void updateControls(int min, int max) {
+    private void updateControls(int min, int max, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages) {
         int totalChosenAmount = 0;
-        for (JSpinner jSpinner : spinnerList) {
+        boolean chooseEnabled = true;
-            totalChosenAmount += ((Number) jSpinner.getValue()).intValue();
+
+        for (int i = 0; i < spinnerList.size(); i++) {
+            JSpinner jSpinner = spinnerList.get(i);
+            int value = ((Number) jSpinner.getValue()).intValue();
+            totalChosenAmount += value;
+
+            chooseEnabled &= value >= messages.get(i).min && value <= messages.get(i).max;
         }
         counterText.setText(totalChosenAmount + " out of " + max);
-        chooseButton.setEnabled(totalChosenAmount >= min && totalChosenAmount <= max);
+
+        chooseEnabled &= totalChosenAmount >= min && totalChosenAmount <= max;
+        chooseButton.setEnabled(chooseEnabled);
     }
 
     public String getMultiAmount() {

Mage.Client/src/main/java/mage/client/game/GamePanel.java

@@ -28,6 +28,7 @@ import mage.constants.*;
 import mage.game.events.PlayerQueryEvent;
 import mage.players.PlayableObjectStats;
 import mage.players.PlayableObjectsList;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.view.*;
 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
 import org.mage.plugins.card.utils.impl.ImageManagerImpl;
@@ -1774,7 +1775,8 @@ public final class GamePanel extends javax.swing.JPanel {
         }
     }
 
-    public void getMultiAmount(List<String> messages, GameView gameView, Map<String, Serializable> options, int min, int max) {
+    public void getMultiAmount(List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, GameView gameView, Map<String, Serializable> options,
+            int min, int max) {
         updateGame(gameView, false, options, null);
         hideAll();
         DialogManager.getManager(gameId).fadeOut();

Mage.Common/src/main/java/mage/view/GameClientMessage.java

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ import com.google.gson.GsonBuilder;
 import com.google.gson.annotations.Expose;
 
 import mage.choices.Choice;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 /**
  *
@@ -42,7 +43,7 @@ public class GameClientMessage implements Serializable {
     @Expose
     private Choice choice;
     @Expose
-    private List<String> messages;
+    private List<MultiAmountMessage> messages;
 
     public GameClientMessage(GameView gameView, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
         this.gameView = gameView;
@@ -80,7 +81,8 @@ public class GameClientMessage implements Serializable {
         this.cardsView2 = pile2;
     }
 
-    public GameClientMessage(GameView gameView, Map<String, Serializable> options, List<String> messages, int min, int max) {
+    public GameClientMessage(GameView gameView, Map<String, Serializable> options, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max) {
         this.gameView = gameView;
         this.options = options;
         this.messages = messages;
@@ -134,7 +136,7 @@ public class GameClientMessage implements Serializable {
         return choice;
     }
 
-    public List<String> getMessages() {
+    public List<MultiAmountMessage> getMessages() {
         return messages;
     }
 

Mage.Server.Plugins/Mage.Player.AI/src/main/java/mage/player/ai/ComputerPlayer.java

@@ -2169,11 +2169,12 @@ public class ComputerPlayer extends PlayerImpl implements Player {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
+    public List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
         log.debug("getMultiAmount");
 
         int needCount = messages.size();
-        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(needCount, min, max);
+        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(messages, min, max);
         if (needCount == 0) {
             return defaultList;
         }
@@ -2188,7 +2189,7 @@ public class ComputerPlayer extends PlayerImpl implements Player {
         // GOOD effect
         // values must be stable, so AI must able to simulate it and choose correct actions
         // fill max values as much as possible
-        return MultiAmountType.prepareMaxValues(needCount, min, max);
+        return MultiAmountType.prepareMaxValues(messages, min, max);
     }
 
     @Override

Mage.Server.Plugins/Mage.Player.Human/src/mage/player/human/HumanPlayer.java

@@ -45,6 +45,8 @@ import mage.util.CardUtil;
 import mage.util.GameLog;
 import mage.util.ManaUtil;
 import mage.util.MessageToClient;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
+
 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
 
 import java.awt.*;
@@ -2049,10 +2051,12 @@ public class HumanPlayer extends PlayerImpl {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
+    public List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
         int needCount = messages.size();
-        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(needCount, min, max);
+        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(messages, min, max);
-        if (needCount == 0) {
+        if (needCount == 0 || (needCount == 1 && min == max)
+                || messages.stream().map(m -> m.min == m.max).reduce(true, Boolean::logicalAnd)) {
             return defaultList;
         }
 
@@ -2074,8 +2078,8 @@ public class HumanPlayer extends PlayerImpl {
 
             // waiting correct values only
             if (response.getString() != null) {
-                answer = MultiAmountType.parseAnswer(response.getString(), needCount, min, max, false);
+                answer = MultiAmountType.parseAnswer(response.getString(), messages, min, max, false);
-                if (MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(answer, needCount, min, max)) {
+                if (MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(answer, messages, min, max)) {
                     break;
                 } else {
                     // it's not normal: can be cheater or a wrong GUI checks

Mage.Server/src/main/java/mage/server/game/GameController.java

@@ -28,6 +28,7 @@ import mage.server.User;
 import mage.server.managers.ManagerFactory;
 import mage.server.util.Splitter;
 import mage.server.util.SystemUtil;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.utils.StreamUtils;
 import mage.utils.timer.PriorityTimer;
 import mage.view.*;
@@ -870,7 +871,9 @@ public class GameController implements GameCallback {
         perform(playerId, playerId1 -> getGameSession(playerId1).getAmount(message, min, max));
     }
 
-    private synchronized void multiAmount(UUID playerId, final List<String> messages, final int min, final int max, final Map<String, Serializable> options) throws MageException {
+    private synchronized void multiAmount(UUID playerId, final List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            final int min, final int max, final Map<String, Serializable> options)
+            throws MageException {
         perform(playerId, playerId1 -> getGameSession(playerId1).getMultiAmount(messages, min, max, options));
     }
 

Mage.Server/src/main/java/mage/server/game/GameSessionPlayer.java

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ import mage.players.Player;
 import mage.server.User;
 import mage.server.managers.ManagerFactory;
 import mage.server.managers.UserManager;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.view.*;
 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
 
@@ -114,7 +115,8 @@ public class GameSessionPlayer extends GameSessionWatcher {
         }
     }
 
-    public void getMultiAmount(final List<String> messages, final int min, final int max, final Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+    public void getMultiAmount(final List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, final int min, final int max,
+            final Map<String, Serializable> options) {
         if (!killed) {
             userManager.getUser(userId).ifPresent(user
                     -> user.fireCallback(new ClientCallback(ClientCallbackMethod.GAME_GET_MULTI_AMOUNT, game.getId(), new GameClientMessage(getGameView(), options, messages, min, max))));

Mage.Sets/src/mage/cards/g/GoldberryRiverDaughter.java

@@ -0,0 +1,183 @@
+package mage.cards.g;
+
+import mage.MageInt;
+import mage.abilities.Ability;
+import mage.abilities.common.SimpleActivatedAbility;
+import mage.abilities.costs.common.TapSourceCost;
+import mage.abilities.costs.mana.ManaCostsImpl;
+import mage.abilities.effects.OneShotEffect;
+import mage.cards.CardImpl;
+import mage.cards.CardSetInfo;
+import mage.constants.*;
+import mage.counters.Counter;
+import mage.counters.CounterType;
+import mage.filter.FilterPermanent;
+import mage.filter.common.FilterControlledPermanent;
+import mage.filter.predicate.mageobject.AnotherPredicate;
+import mage.game.Game;
+import mage.game.permanent.Permanent;
+import mage.players.Player;
+import mage.target.TargetPermanent;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
+
+import java.util.*;
+import java.util.stream.Collectors;
+
+/**
+ * @author alexander_novo
+ */
+public final class GoldberryRiverDaughter extends CardImpl {
+
+    private static final FilterPermanent filter = new FilterControlledPermanent("another target permanent you control");
+
+    static {
+        filter.add(AnotherPredicate.instance);
+    }
+
+    public GoldberryRiverDaughter(UUID ownerId, CardSetInfo setInfo) {
+        super(ownerId, setInfo, new CardType[] { CardType.CREATURE }, "{1}{U}");
+
+        this.supertype.add(SuperType.LEGENDARY);
+        this.subtype.add(SubType.NYMPH);
+        this.power = new MageInt(1);
+        this.toughness = new MageInt(3);
+
+        // {T}: Move a counter of each kind not on Goldberry, River-Daughter from another target permanent you control onto Goldberry.
+        SimpleActivatedAbility abilityFrom = new SimpleActivatedAbility(new GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect(),
+                new TapSourceCost());
+        abilityFrom.addTarget(new TargetPermanent(filter));
+        this.addAbility(abilityFrom);
+
+        // {U}, {T}: Move one or more counters from Goldberry onto another target permanent you control. If you do, draw a card.
+        SimpleActivatedAbility abilityTo = new SimpleActivatedAbility(new GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect(),
+                new ManaCostsImpl<>("{U}"));
+        abilityTo.addCost(new TapSourceCost());
+        abilityTo.addTarget(new TargetPermanent(filter));
+        this.addAbility(abilityTo);
+    }
+
+    private GoldberryRiverDaughter(final GoldberryRiverDaughter card) {
+        super(card);
+    }
+
+    @Override
+    public GoldberryRiverDaughter copy() {
+        return new GoldberryRiverDaughter(this);
+    }
+}
+
+class GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect extends OneShotEffect {
+    GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect() {
+        super(Outcome.Neutral);
+        staticText = "Move a counter of each kind not on {this} from another target permanent you control onto Goldberry.";
+    }
+
+    private GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect(final GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect effect) {
+        super(effect);
+    }
+
+    @Override
+    public GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect copy() {
+        return new GoldberryRiverDaughterFromEffect(this);
+    }
+
+    @Override
+    public boolean apply(Game game, Ability source) {
+        Player controller = game.getPlayer(source.getControllerId());
+        Permanent fromPermanent = game.getPermanent(source.getFirstTarget());
+        Permanent toPermanent = game.getPermanent(source.getSourceId());
+
+        // Create a set of all of the unique counter types on the target permanent that aren't on Goldberry
+        Set<Counter> fromCounters = new HashSet<Counter>(fromPermanent.getCounters(game).values());
+        fromCounters.removeAll(toPermanent.getCounters(game).values());
+
+        if (fromPermanent == null
+                || toPermanent == null
+                || controller == null
+                || fromCounters.size() == 0) {
+            return false;
+        }
+
+        for (Counter counter : fromCounters) {
+            fromPermanent.removeCounters(counter.getName(), 1, source, game);
+            toPermanent.addCounters(CounterType.findByName(counter.getName()).createInstance(1),
+                    source.getControllerId(), source, game);
+        }
+        return true;
+    }
+}
+
+class GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect extends OneShotEffect {
+    GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect() {
+        super(Outcome.Neutral);
+        staticText = "Move one or more counters from Goldberry onto another target permanent you control. If you do, draw a card.";
+    }
+
+    private GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect(final GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect effect) {
+        super(effect);
+    }
+
+    @Override
+    public GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect copy() {
+        return new GoldberryRiverDaughterToEffect(this);
+    }
+
+    @Override
+    public boolean apply(Game game, Ability source) {
+        Player controller = game.getPlayer(source.getControllerId());
+        Permanent toPermanent = game.getPermanent(source.getFirstTarget());
+        Permanent fromPermanent = game.getPermanent(source.getSourceId());
+
+        if (fromPermanent == null
+                || toPermanent == null
+                || controller == null
+                || fromPermanent.getCounters(game).size() == 0) {
+            return false;
+        }
+
+        List<Counter> counters = new ArrayList<>(fromPermanent.getCounters(game).values());
+        counters.sort((c1, c2) -> c1.getName().compareTo(c2.getName()));
+
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> messages = counters.stream()
+                .map(c -> new MultiAmountMessage(c.getName() + " (" + c.getCount() + ")", 0, c.getCount()))
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
+        int max = messages.stream().map(m -> m.max).reduce(0, Integer::sum);
+
+        int total;
+        List<Integer> choices;
+        do {
+            choices = controller.getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome.Neutral, messages, 1,
+                    max, MultiAmountType.COUNTERS, game);
+
+            total = choices.stream().reduce(0, Integer::sum);
+        } while (total < 1);
+
+        // Move the counters. Make sure some counters were actually moved.
+        boolean movedCounters = false;
+        for (int i = 0; i < choices.size(); i++) {
+            Integer amount = choices.get(i);
+
+            if (amount > 0) {
+                String counterName = counters.get(i).getName();
+
+                movedCounters |= toPermanent.addCounters(
+                        CounterType.findByName(counterName).createInstance(amount),
+                        source,
+                        game);
+                fromPermanent.removeCounters(counterName, amount, source, game);
+                game.informPlayers(
+                        controller.getLogName() + "moved " +
+                                amount + " " +
+                                counterName + " counter" + (amount > 1 ? "s" : "") +
+                                " from " + fromPermanent.getLogName() +
+                                "to " + toPermanent.getLogName() + ".");
+            }
+        }
+
+        // If some counters were actually moved, draw a card
+        if (movedCounters) {
+            controller.drawCards(1, source, game);
+        }
+        return false;
+    }
+}

Mage.Sets/src/mage/cards/r/ResourcefulDefense.java

@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ import mage.abilities.effects.OneShotEffect;
 import mage.cards.CardImpl;
 import mage.cards.CardSetInfo;
 import mage.constants.CardType;
+import mage.constants.MultiAmountType;
 import mage.constants.Outcome;
 import mage.counters.Counter;
 import mage.counters.CounterType;
@@ -24,10 +25,12 @@ import mage.players.Player;
 import mage.target.Target;
 import mage.target.TargetPermanent;
 import mage.target.common.TargetControlledPermanent;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
-import java.util.HashMap;
+import java.util.ArrayList;
-import java.util.Map;
+import java.util.List;
 import java.util.UUID;
+import java.util.stream.Collectors;
 
 /**
  * @author Alex-Vasile
@@ -92,33 +95,39 @@ class ResourcefulDefenseMoveCounterEffect extends OneShotEffect {
             return false;
         }
 
-        // Counter name and how many to move
+        List<Counter> counters = new ArrayList<>(fromPermanent.getCounters(game).values());
-        Map<String, Integer> counterMap = new HashMap<>();
+        counters.sort((c1, c2) -> c1.getName().compareTo(c2.getName()));
-        for (Map.Entry<String, Counter> entry : fromPermanent.getCounters(game).entrySet()) {
-            int num = controller.getAmount(
-                    0,
-                    entry.getValue().getCount(),
-                    "Choose how many " + entry.getKey() +
-                            " counters to remove from " + fromPermanent.getLogName(),
-                    game);
-            int newAmount = num + counterMap.getOrDefault(entry.getKey(), 0);
-            counterMap.put(entry.getKey(), newAmount);
-        }
 
-        // Move the counters
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> messages = counters.stream()
-        for (String counterName : counterMap.keySet()) {
+                .map(c -> new MultiAmountMessage(c.getName() + " (" + c.getCount() + ")", 0, c.getCount()))
-            toPermanent.addCounters(
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
-                    CounterType.findByName(counterName).createInstance(counterMap.get(counterName)),
+        int max = messages.stream().map(m -> m.max).reduce(0, Integer::sum);
-                    source,
+
-                    game);
+        int total;
-            fromPermanent.removeCounters(counterName, counterMap.get(counterName), source, game);
+        List<Integer> choices;
+        do {
+            choices = controller.getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome.Neutral, messages, 0,
+                    max, MultiAmountType.COUNTERS, game);
+
+            total = choices.stream().reduce(0, Integer::sum);
+        } while (total < 0);
+
+        // Move the counters. Make sure some counters were actually moved.
+        for (int i = 0; i < choices.size(); i++) {
+            Integer amount = choices.get(i);
+
+            if (amount > 0) {
+                String counterName = counters.get(i).getName();
+
+                toPermanent.addCounters(CounterType.findByName(counterName).createInstance(amount), source, game);
+                fromPermanent.removeCounters(counterName, amount, source, game);
                 game.informPlayers(
                         controller.getLogName() + "moved " +
-                    counterMap.get(counterName) + " " +
+                                amount + " " +
-                    counterName + "counter" + (counterMap.get(counterName) > 1 ? "s" : "") +
+                                counterName + " counter" + (amount > 1 ? "s" : "") +
-                    "from " + fromPermanent.getLogName() +
+                                " from " + fromPermanent.getLogName() +
-                    "to " + toPermanent.getLogName() + "."
+                                "to " + toPermanent.getLogName() + ".");
-            );
+            }
         }
 
         return true;

Mage.Sets/src/mage/sets/TheLordOfTheRingsTalesOfMiddleEarth.java

@@ -125,6 +125,7 @@ public final class TheLordOfTheRingsTalesOfMiddleEarth extends ExpansionSet {
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Glorious Gale", 51, Rarity.COMMON, mage.cards.g.GloriousGale.class));
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Goblin Assailant", 295, Rarity.COMMON, mage.cards.g.GoblinAssailant.class));
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Goblin Fireleaper", 133, Rarity.UNCOMMON, mage.cards.g.GoblinFireleaper.class));
+        cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Goldberry, River-Daughter", 52, Rarity.RARE, mage.cards.g.GoldberryRiverDaughter.class));
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Gollum's Bite", 85, Rarity.UNCOMMON, mage.cards.g.GollumsBite.class));
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Gollum, Patient Plotter", 84, Rarity.UNCOMMON, mage.cards.g.GollumPatientPlotter.class));
         cards.add(new SetCardInfo("Gollum, Scheming Guide", 292, Rarity.RARE, mage.cards.g.GollumSchemingGuide.class));

Mage.Tests/src/test/java/org/mage/test/cards/single/ltr/GoldberryRiverDaughterTest.java

@@ -0,0 +1,145 @@
+package org.mage.test.cards.single.ltr;
+
+import org.junit.Test;
+import org.mage.test.serverside.base.CardTestPlayerBase;
+
+import mage.constants.PhaseStep;
+import mage.constants.Zone;
+import mage.counters.CounterType;
+
+public class GoldberryRiverDaughterTest extends CardTestPlayerBase {
+    static final String goldberry = "Goldberry, River-Daughter";
+    static final String ability1 = "{T}: Move a counter of each kind not on {this} from another target permanent you control onto Goldberry.";
+    static final String ability2 = "{U}, {T}: Move one or more counters from Goldberry onto another target permanent you control. If you do, draw a card.";
+
+    @Test
+    // Author: alexander-novo
+    // Happy path test - remove some counters from something. Then put some of them on something else.
+    public void testHappyPath() {
+        CounterType counter1 = CounterType.ACORN;
+        CounterType counter2 = CounterType.AEGIS;
+        String island = "Island";
+
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, goldberry, 1);
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, island, 1);
+
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter1, 2);
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter2, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability1, island);
+        waitStackResolved(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+
+        checkPermanentCounters("First Ability", 1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter1, 1);
+        checkPermanentCounters("First Ability", 1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter2, 0);
+        checkPermanentCounters("First Ability", 1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, goldberry, counter1, 1);
+        checkPermanentCounters("First Ability", 1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, goldberry, counter2, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(3, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability2, island);
+        waitStackResolved(3, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+        setChoiceAmount(playerA, 0, 1); // acorn, aegis counters
+
+        setStrictChooseMode(true);
+        setStopAt(3, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN);
+        execute();
+
+        assertCounterCount(island, counter1, 1);
+        assertCounterCount(island, counter2, 1);
+        assertCounterCount(goldberry, counter1, 1);
+        assertCounterCount(goldberry, counter2, 0);
+
+        // One from turn 2 draw, one from goldberry
+        assertHandCount(playerA, 2);
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    // Author: alexander-novo
+    // Unhappy path - Try to remove some counters from something when some of those counters are already on Goldberry
+    public void testCounterAlreadyOnGoldberry() {
+        CounterType counter = CounterType.ACORN;
+        String island = "Island";
+
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, goldberry, 1);
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, island, 1);
+
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter, 1);
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, goldberry, counter, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability1, island);
+        waitStackResolved(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+
+        setStrictChooseMode(true);
+        setStopAt(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN);
+        execute();
+
+        assertCounterCount(island, counter, 1);
+        assertCounterCount(goldberry, counter, 1);
+    }
+
+    @Test(expected = AssertionError.class)
+    // Author: alexander-novo
+    // Unhappy path - Try to not move a counter from Goldberry even though she has a counter on her.
+    // Should fail since we are attempting to move 0 counters, even though we must move at least one if possible.
+    public void testNotMovingCounter() {
+        CounterType counter = CounterType.ACORN;
+        String island = "Island";
+
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, goldberry, 1);
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, island, 1);
+
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, goldberry, counter, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability2, island);
+        waitStackResolved(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+        setChoiceAmount(playerA, 0); // Try to remove 0 counters from goldberry
+
+        setStrictChooseMode(true);
+        setStopAt(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN);
+        execute();
+
+        assertCounterCount(goldberry, counter, 0);
+        assertCounterCount(island, counter, 1);
+        assertHandCount(playerA, 1);
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    // Author: alexander-novo
+    // Unhappy path - Activate second ability with no counters on Goldberry
+    public void testNoCounters() {
+        String island = "Island";
+
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, goldberry, 1);
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, island, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability2, island);
+        waitStackResolved(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+
+        setStrictChooseMode(true);
+        setStopAt(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN);
+        execute();
+
+        assertHandCount(playerA, 0);
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    // Author: alexander-novo
+    // Bug - Goldberry doesn't seem to get some of the effects from some of the counters she takes
+    public void testM1M1Counters() {
+        CounterType counter = CounterType.M1M1;
+        String island = "Island";
+
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, goldberry, 1);
+        addCard(Zone.BATTLEFIELD, playerA, island, 1);
+
+        addCounters(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, island, counter, 1);
+
+        activateAbility(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, ability1, island);
+        waitStackResolved(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, 1);
+
+        setStrictChooseMode(true);
+        setStopAt(1, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN);
+        execute();
+
+        assertCounterCount(goldberry, counter, 1);
+        assertPowerToughness(playerA, goldberry, 0, 2);
+    }
+}

Mage.Tests/src/test/java/org/mage/test/cards/single/ncc/ResourcefulDefenseTest.java

@@ -115,8 +115,7 @@ public class ResourcefulDefenseTest extends CardTestPlayerBase {
         activateAbility(3, PhaseStep.PRECOMBAT_MAIN, playerA, "{4}{W}: ");
         addTarget(playerA, steelbaneHydra);
         addTarget(playerA, vividCreek);
-        setChoiceAmount(playerA, 2);
+        setChoiceAmount(playerA, 1, 2); // +1/+1, Charge
-        setChoiceAmount(playerA, 1);
 
         setStopAt(3, PhaseStep.END_TURN);
         execute();

Mage.Tests/src/test/java/org/mage/test/cards/targets/TargetMultiAmountTest.java

@@ -3,6 +3,8 @@ package org.mage.test.cards.targets;
 import mage.constants.MultiAmountType;
 import mage.constants.PhaseStep;
 import mage.constants.Zone;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
+
 import org.junit.Assert;
 import org.junit.Test;
 import org.mage.test.player.TestPlayer;
@@ -10,6 +12,7 @@ import org.mage.test.serverside.base.CardTestPlayerBaseWithAIHelps;
 
 import java.util.List;
 import java.util.stream.Collectors;
+import java.util.stream.IntStream;
 
 /**
  * @author JayDi85
@@ -20,117 +23,132 @@ public class TargetMultiAmountTest extends CardTestPlayerBaseWithAIHelps {
     @Test
     public void test_DefaultValues() {
         // default values must be assigned from first to last by minimum values
-        assertDefaultValues("", 0, 0, 0);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("", 0, 0, 0);
         //
-        assertDefaultValues("0", 1, 0, 0);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("0", 1, 0, 0);
-        assertDefaultValues("0 0", 2, 0, 0);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("0 0", 2, 0, 0);
-        assertDefaultValues("0 0 0", 3, 0, 0);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("0 0 0", 3, 0, 0);
         //
-        assertDefaultValues("1", 1, 1, 1);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1", 1, 1, 1);
-        assertDefaultValues("1 0", 2, 1, 1);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1 0", 2, 1, 1);
-        assertDefaultValues("1 0 0", 3, 1, 1);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 1);
         //
-        assertDefaultValues("1", 1, 1, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1", 1, 1, 2);
-        assertDefaultValues("1 0", 2, 1, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1 0", 2, 1, 2);
-        assertDefaultValues("1 0 0", 3, 1, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 2);
         //
-        assertDefaultValues("2", 1, 2, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2", 1, 2, 2);
-        assertDefaultValues("2 0", 2, 2, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2 0", 2, 2, 2);
-        assertDefaultValues("2 0 0", 3, 2, 2);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2 0 0", 3, 2, 2);
         //
-        assertDefaultValues("2", 1, 2, 10);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2", 1, 2, 10);
-        assertDefaultValues("2 0", 2, 2, 10);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2 0", 2, 2, 10);
-        assertDefaultValues("2 0 0", 3, 2, 10);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2 0 0", 3, 2, 10);
         //
         // performance test
-        assertDefaultValues("2 0 0", 3, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
+        assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained("2 0 0", 3, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
     }
 
-    private void assertDefaultValues(String need, int count, int min, int max) {
+    private List<MultiAmountMessage> getUnconstrainedConstraints(int count) {
-        List<Integer> defaultValues = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(count, min, max);
+        return IntStream.range(0, count).mapToObj(i -> new MultiAmountMessage("", Integer.MIN_VALUE, Integer.MAX_VALUE))
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
+    }
+
+    private void assertDefaultValuesUnconstrained(String need, int count, int min, int max) {
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints = getUnconstrainedConstraints(count);
+        List<Integer> defaultValues = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(constraints, min, max);
         String current = defaultValues
                 .stream()
                 .map(String::valueOf)
                 .collect(Collectors.joining(" "));
         Assert.assertEquals("default values", need, current);
-        Assert.assertTrue("default values must be good", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(defaultValues, count, min, max));
+        Assert.assertTrue("default values must be good",
+                MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(defaultValues, constraints, min, max));
     }
 
     @Test
     public void test_MaxValues() {
         // max possible values must be assigned from first to last by max possible values
-        assertMaxValues("", 0, 0, 0);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("", 0, 0, 0);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("0", 1, 0, 0);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("0", 1, 0, 0);
-        assertMaxValues("0 0", 2, 0, 0);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("0 0", 2, 0, 0);
-        assertMaxValues("0 0 0", 3, 0, 0);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("0 0 0", 3, 0, 0);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("1", 1, 1, 1);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1", 1, 1, 1);
-        assertMaxValues("1 0", 2, 1, 1);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 0", 2, 1, 1);
-        assertMaxValues("1 0 0", 3, 1, 1);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 1);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("2", 1, 1, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("2", 1, 1, 2);
-        assertMaxValues("1 1", 2, 1, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 1", 2, 1, 2);
-        assertMaxValues("1 1 0", 3, 1, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 1 0", 3, 1, 2);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("2", 1, 2, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("2", 1, 2, 2);
-        assertMaxValues("1 1", 2, 2, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 1", 2, 2, 2);
-        assertMaxValues("1 1 0", 3, 2, 2);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 1 0", 3, 2, 2);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("10", 1, 2, 10);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("10", 1, 2, 10);
-        assertMaxValues("5 5", 2, 2, 10);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("5 5", 2, 2, 10);
-        assertMaxValues("4 3 3", 3, 2, 10);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("4 3 3", 3, 2, 10);
         //
-        assertMaxValues("1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0", 10, 2, 5);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained("1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0", 10, 2, 5);
         //
         // performance test
-        assertMaxValues(String.valueOf(Integer.MAX_VALUE), 1, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained(String.valueOf(Integer.MAX_VALUE), 1, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
         int part = Integer.MAX_VALUE / 3;
         String need = String.format("%d %d %d", part + 1, part, part);
-        assertMaxValues(need, 3, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
+        assertMaxValuesUnconstrained(need, 3, 2, Integer.MAX_VALUE);
     }
 
-    private void assertMaxValues(String need, int count, int min, int max) {
+    private void assertMaxValuesUnconstrained(String need, int count, int min, int max) {
-        List<Integer> maxValues = MultiAmountType.prepareMaxValues(count, min, max);
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints = getUnconstrainedConstraints(count);
+        List<Integer> maxValues = MultiAmountType.prepareMaxValues(constraints, min, max);
         String current = maxValues
                 .stream()
                 .map(String::valueOf)
                 .collect(Collectors.joining(" "));
         Assert.assertEquals("max values", need, current);
-        Assert.assertTrue("max values must be good", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(maxValues, count, min, max));
+        Assert.assertTrue("max values must be good", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(maxValues, constraints, min, max));
     }
 
     @Test
     public void test_GoodValues() {
+        List<List<MultiAmountMessage>> constraints = List.of(
+                getUnconstrainedConstraints(0),
+                getUnconstrainedConstraints(1),
+                getUnconstrainedConstraints(2),
+                getUnconstrainedConstraints(3),
+                getUnconstrainedConstraints(4));
+
         // good values are checking in test_DefaultValues, it's an additional
-        List<Integer> list = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(3, 0, 0);
+        List<Integer> list = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(constraints.get(3), 0, 0);
 
         // count (0, 0, 0)
-        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 0, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(0), 0, 0));
-        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 1, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(1), 0, 0));
-        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 2, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(2), 0, 0));
-        Assert.assertTrue("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertTrue("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 0));
-        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 4, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertFalse("count", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(4), 0, 0));
 
         // min (0, 1, 1)
         list.set(0, 0);
         list.set(1, 1);
         list.set(2, 1);
-        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 100));
+        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 100));
-        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 1, 100));
+        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 1, 100));
-        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 2, 100));
+        Assert.assertTrue("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 2, 100));
-        Assert.assertFalse("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 3, 100));
+        Assert.assertFalse("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 3, 100));
-        Assert.assertFalse("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 4, 100));
+        Assert.assertFalse("min", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 4, 100));
 
         // max (0, 1, 1)
         list.set(0, 0);
         list.set(1, 1);
         list.set(2, 1);
-        Assert.assertFalse("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 0));
+        Assert.assertFalse("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 0));
-        Assert.assertFalse("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 1));
+        Assert.assertFalse("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 1));
-        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 2));
+        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 2));
-        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 3));
+        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 3));
-        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, 3, 0, 4));
+        Assert.assertTrue("max", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(list, constraints.get(3), 0, 4));
     }
 
     @Test
@@ -138,32 +156,36 @@ public class TargetMultiAmountTest extends CardTestPlayerBaseWithAIHelps {
         // parse must use correct values on good data or default values on broken data
 
         // simple parse without data check
-        assertParse("", 3, 1, 3, "", false);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("", 3, 1, 3, "", false);
-        assertParse("1", 3, 1, 3, "1", false);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1", 3, 1, 3, "1", false);
-        assertParse("0 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "0 0 0", false);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("0 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "0 0 0", false);
-        assertParse("1 0 3", 3, 1, 3, "1 0 3", false);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 3", 3, 1, 3, "1 0 3", false);
-        assertParse("0 5 0 6", 3, 1, 3, "1,text 5 4. 6", false);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("0 5 0 6", 3, 1, 3, "1,text 5 4. 6", false);
 
         // parse with data check - good data
-        assertParse("1 0 2", 3, 0, 3, "1 0 2", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 2", 3, 0, 3, "1 0 2", true);
 
         // parse with data check - broken data (must return defalt - 1 0 0)
-        assertParse("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "", true);
-        assertParse("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1", true);
-        assertParse("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "0 0 0", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "0 0 0", true);
-        assertParse("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1 0 3", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1 0 3", true);
-        assertParse("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1,text 4.", true);
+        assertParseUnconstrained("1 0 0", 3, 1, 3, "1,text 4.", true);
     }
 
-    private void assertParse(String need, int count, int min, int max, String answerToParse, Boolean returnDefaultOnError) {
+    private void assertParseUnconstrained(String need, int count, int min, int max, String answerToParse,
-        List<Integer> parsedValues = MultiAmountType.parseAnswer(answerToParse, count, min, max, returnDefaultOnError);
+            Boolean returnDefaultOnError) {
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints = getUnconstrainedConstraints(count);
+        List<Integer> parsedValues = MultiAmountType.parseAnswer(answerToParse, constraints, min, max,
+                returnDefaultOnError);
         String current = parsedValues
                 .stream()
                 .map(String::valueOf)
                 .collect(Collectors.joining(" "));
         Assert.assertEquals("parsed values", need, current);
         if (returnDefaultOnError) {
-            Assert.assertTrue("parsed values must be good", MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(parsedValues, count, min, max));
+            Assert.assertTrue("parsed values must be good",
+                    MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(parsedValues, constraints, min, max));
         }
     }
 

Mage.Tests/src/test/java/org/mage/test/player/TestPlayer.java

@@ -49,6 +49,7 @@ import mage.players.net.UserData;
 import mage.target.*;
 import mage.target.common.*;
 import mage.util.CardUtil;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.util.RandomUtil;
 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
 import org.junit.Assert;
@@ -2831,11 +2832,12 @@ public class TestPlayer implements Player {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
+    public List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
         assertAliasSupportInChoices(false);
 
         int needCount = messages.size();
-        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(needCount, min, max);
+        List<Integer> defaultList = MultiAmountType.prepareDefaltValues(messages, min, max);
         if (needCount == 0) {
             return defaultList;
         }
@@ -2861,7 +2863,7 @@ public class TestPlayer implements Player {
             }
 
             // extra check
-            if (!MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(answer, needCount, min, max)) {
+            if (!MultiAmountType.isGoodValues(answer, messages, min, max)) {
                 Assert.fail("Wrong choices in multi amount: " + answer
                         .stream()
                         .map(String::valueOf)
@@ -2872,7 +2874,7 @@ public class TestPlayer implements Player {
         }
 
         this.chooseStrictModeFailed("choice", game, "Multi amount: " + type.getHeader());
-        return computerPlayer.getMultiAmount(outcome, messages, min, max, type, game);
+        return computerPlayer.getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(outcome, messages, min, max, type, game);
     }
 
     @Override

Mage.Tests/src/test/java/org/mage/test/stub/PlayerStub.java

@@ -42,6 +42,7 @@ import mage.target.Target;
 import mage.target.TargetAmount;
 import mage.target.TargetCard;
 import mage.target.common.TargetCardInLibrary;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 import java.io.Serializable;
 import java.util.*;
@@ -983,7 +984,8 @@ public class PlayerStub implements Player {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
+    public List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
         return null;
     }
 

Mage/src/main/java/mage/constants/MultiAmountType.java

@@ -1,19 +1,19 @@
 package mage.constants;
 
-import com.google.common.collect.Iterables;
 import mage.util.CardUtil;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 import java.util.ArrayList;
 import java.util.Arrays;
-import java.util.Iterator;
 import java.util.List;
-import java.util.stream.IntStream;
+import java.util.stream.Collectors;
 
 public enum MultiAmountType {
 
     MANA("Add mana", "Distribute mana among colors"),
     DAMAGE("Assign damage", "Assign damage among targets"),
-    P1P1("Add +1/+1 counters", "Distribute +1/+1 counters among creatures");
+    P1P1("Add +1/+1 counters", "Distribute +1/+1 counters among creatures"),
+    COUNTERS("Choose counters", "Move counters");
 
     private final String title;
     private final String header;
@@ -31,63 +31,125 @@ public enum MultiAmountType {
         return header;
     }
 
-    public static List<Integer> prepareDefaltValues(int count, int min, int max) {
+    public static List<Integer> prepareDefaltValues(List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints, int min, int max) {
         // default values must be assigned from first to last by minimum values
-        List<Integer> res = new ArrayList<>();
+        List<Integer> res = constraints.stream().map(m -> m.min > Integer.MIN_VALUE ? m.min : (0 < max ? 0 : max))
-        if (count == 0) {
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
+        if (res.isEmpty()) {
             return res;
         }
 
-        // fill list
+        int total = res.stream().reduce(0, Integer::sum);
-        IntStream.range(0, count).forEach(i -> res.add(0));
 
-        // fill values
+        // Fill values until we reach the overall minimum. Do this by filling values up until either their max or however much is leftover, starting with the first option.
-        if (min > 0) {
+        if (min > 0 && total < min) {
-            res.set(0, min);
+            int left = min - total;
+            for (int i = 0; i < res.size(); i++) {
+                // How much space there is left to add to 
+                if (constraints.get(i).max == Integer.MAX_VALUE || constraints.get(i).max - res.get(i) > left) {
+                    res.set(i, res.get(i) + left);
+                    break;
+                } else {
+                    int add = constraints.get(i).max - res.get(i);
+                    res.set(i, constraints.get(i).max);
+
+                    left -= add;
+                }
+            }
         }
 
         return res;
     }
 
-    public static List<Integer> prepareMaxValues(int count, int min, int max) {
+    public static List<Integer> prepareMaxValues(List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints, int min, int max) {
-        // fill max values as much as possible
+        if (constraints.isEmpty()) {
-        List<Integer> res = new ArrayList<>();
+            return new ArrayList<Integer>();
-        if (count == 0) {
-            return res;
         }
 
-        // fill list
+        // Start by filling in minimum values where it makes sense
-        int startingValue = max / count;
+        int default_val = max / constraints.size();
-        IntStream.range(0, count).forEach(i -> res.add(startingValue));
+        List<Integer> res = constraints.stream()
+                .map(m -> m.min > Integer.MIN_VALUE ? m.min : (default_val < m.max ? default_val : m.max))
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
 
-        // fill values
+        // Total should fall between the sum of all of the minimum values and max (in the case that everything was filled with default_value).
-        // from first to last until complete
+        // So, we'll never start with too much.
-        List<Integer> resIndexes = new ArrayList<>(res.size());
+        int total = res.stream().reduce(0, Integer::sum);
-        IntStream.range(0, res.size()).forEach(resIndexes::add);
+
-        // infinite iterator (no needs with starting values use, but can be used later for different logic)
+        // So add some values evenly until we hit max
-        Iterator<Integer> resIterator = Iterables.cycle(resIndexes).iterator();
+        while (total < max) {
-        int valueInc = 1;
+            // Find the most amount we can add to several items at once without going over the maximum values
-        int valueTotal = startingValue * count;
+            int addable = Integer.MIN_VALUE;
-        while (valueTotal < max) {
+            List<Integer> consider = new ArrayList<Integer>();
-            int currentIndex = resIterator.next();
+            for (int i = 0; i < res.size(); i++) {
-            int newValue = CardUtil.overflowInc(res.get(currentIndex), valueInc);
+
-            res.set(currentIndex, newValue);
+                if (constraints.get(i).max == Integer.MAX_VALUE) {
-            valueTotal += valueInc;
+                    consider.add(i);
+                } else {
+                    int diff = constraints.get(i).max - res.get(i);
+                    if (diff > 0) {
+                        consider.add(i);
+                        if (diff < addable) {
+                            addable = diff;
+                        }
+                    }
+                }
+            }
+
+            // We hit max for all of the individual constraints - so this is as far as we can go.
+            if (consider.isEmpty()) {
+                break;
+            }
+
+            if (addable > Integer.MIN_VALUE && total + addable * consider.size() < max) {
+                for (int i : consider) {
+                    res.set(i, res.get(i) + addable);
+                }
+                total += addable * consider.size();
+            } else {
+                addable = (max - total) / consider.size();
+                int extras = (max - total) % consider.size();
+
+                for (int i = 0; i < consider.size(); i++) {
+                    // Remove from the end options first
+                    int idx = consider.get(i);
+
+                    // Add the extras evenly to the first options
+                    if (i < extras) {
+                        res.set(idx, res.get(idx) + addable + 1);
+                    } else {
+                        res.set(idx, res.get(idx) + addable);
+                    }
+                }
+
+                total = max;
+            }
         }
 
         return res;
     }
 
-    public static boolean isGoodValues(List<Integer> values, int count, int min, int max) {
+    public static boolean isGoodValues(List<Integer> values, List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints, int min, int max) {
-        if (values.size() != count) {
+        if (values.size() != constraints.size()) {
             return false;
         }
 
-        int currentSum = values.stream().mapToInt(i -> i).sum();
+        int currentSum = 0;
+        for (int i = 0; i < values.size(); i++) {
+            int value = values.get(i);
+
+            if (value < constraints.get(i).min || value > constraints.get(i).max) {
+                return false;
+            }
+
+            currentSum += value;
+        }
+
         return currentSum >= min && currentSum <= max;
     }
 
-    public static List<Integer> parseAnswer(String answerToParse, int count, int min, int max, boolean returnDefaultOnError) {
+    public static List<Integer> parseAnswer(String answerToParse, List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints, int min,
+            int max, boolean returnDefaultOnError) {
         List<Integer> res = new ArrayList<>();
 
         // parse
@@ -99,9 +161,9 @@ public enum MultiAmountType {
         }
 
         // data check
-        if (returnDefaultOnError && !isGoodValues(res, count, min, max)) {
+        if (returnDefaultOnError && !isGoodValues(res, constraints, min, max)) {
             // on broken data - return default
-            return prepareDefaltValues(count, min, max);
+            return prepareDefaltValues(constraints, min, max);
         }
 
         return res;

Mage/src/main/java/mage/game/Game.java

@@ -39,6 +39,7 @@ import mage.players.PlayerList;
 import mage.players.Players;
 import mage.util.Copyable;
 import mage.util.MessageToClient;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.util.functions.CopyApplier;
 
 import java.io.Serializable;
@@ -301,7 +302,7 @@ public interface Game extends MageItem, Serializable, Copyable<Game> {
 
     void fireGetAmountEvent(UUID playerId, String message, int min, int max);
 
-    void fireGetMultiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<String> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options);
+    void fireGetMultiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options);
 
     void fireChoosePileEvent(UUID playerId, String message, List<? extends Card> pile1, List<? extends Card> pile2);
 

Mage/src/main/java/mage/game/GameImpl.java

@@ -66,6 +66,7 @@ import mage.target.TargetPlayer;
 import mage.util.CardUtil;
 import mage.util.GameLog;
 import mage.util.MessageToClient;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 import mage.util.RandomUtil;
 import mage.util.functions.CopyApplier;
 import mage.watchers.Watcher;
@@ -2885,7 +2886,8 @@ public abstract class GameImpl implements Game {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public void fireGetMultiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<String> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+    public void fireGetMultiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min, int max,
+            Map<String, Serializable> options) {
         if (simulation) {
             return;
         }

Mage/src/main/java/mage/game/events/PlayerQueryEvent.java

@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ import mage.cards.Cards;
 import mage.choices.Choice;
 import mage.game.permanent.Permanent;
 import mage.util.CardUtil;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 /**
  *
@@ -60,11 +61,11 @@ public class PlayerQueryEvent extends EventObject implements ExternalEvent, Seri
     private List<? extends Card> pile1;
     private List<? extends Card> pile2;
     private Choice choice;
-    private List<String> messages;
+    private List<MultiAmountMessage> messages;
 
     private PlayerQueryEvent(UUID playerId, String message, List<? extends Ability> abilities, Set<String> choices,
-                             Set<UUID> targets, Cards cards, QueryType queryType, int min, int max, boolean required,
+            Set<UUID> targets, Cards cards, QueryType queryType, int min, int max,
-                             Map<String, Serializable> options, List<String> messages) {
+            boolean required, Map<String, Serializable> options, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages) {
         super(playerId);
 
         CardUtil.checkSetParamForSerializationCompatibility(choices);
@@ -216,8 +217,10 @@ public class PlayerQueryEvent extends EventObject implements ExternalEvent, Seri
         return new PlayerQueryEvent(playerId, message, null, null, null, null, QueryType.AMOUNT, min, max, false, null, null);
     }
 
-    public static PlayerQueryEvent multiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<String> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+    public static PlayerQueryEvent multiAmountEvent(UUID playerId, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min,
-        return new PlayerQueryEvent(playerId, null, null, null, null, null, QueryType.MULTI_AMOUNT, min, max, false, options, messages);
+            int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+        return new PlayerQueryEvent(playerId, null, null, null, null, null, QueryType.MULTI_AMOUNT, min, max, false,
+                options, messages);
     }
 
     public static PlayerQueryEvent pickCard(UUID playerId, String message, List<Card> booster, int time) {
@@ -300,7 +303,7 @@ public class PlayerQueryEvent extends EventObject implements ExternalEvent, Seri
         return choice;
     }
 
-    public List<String> getMessages() {
+    public List<MultiAmountMessage> getMessages() {
         return messages;
     }
 }

Mage/src/main/java/mage/game/events/PlayerQueryEventSource.java

@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ import mage.cards.Card;
 import mage.cards.Cards;
 import mage.choices.Choice;
 import mage.game.permanent.Permanent;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 /**
  *
@@ -84,7 +85,8 @@ public class PlayerQueryEventSource implements EventSource<PlayerQueryEvent>, Se
         dispatcher.fireEvent(PlayerQueryEvent.amountEvent(playerId, message, min, max));
     }
 
-    public void multiAmount(UUID playerId, List<String> messages, int min, int max, Map<String, Serializable> options) {
+    public void multiAmount(UUID playerId, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min, int max,
+            Map<String, Serializable> options) {
         dispatcher.fireEvent(PlayerQueryEvent.multiAmountEvent(playerId, messages, min, max, options));
     }
 

Mage/src/main/java/mage/players/Player.java

@@ -38,9 +38,11 @@ import mage.target.TargetAmount;
 import mage.target.TargetCard;
 import mage.target.common.TargetCardInLibrary;
 import mage.util.Copyable;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 import java.io.Serializable;
 import java.util.*;
+import java.util.stream.Collectors;
 
 /**
  * @author BetaSteward_at_googlemail.com
@@ -746,7 +748,27 @@ public interface Player extends MageItem, Copyable<Player> {
      * @param game     Game
      * @return List of integers with size equal to messages.size().  The sum of the integers is equal to max.
      */
-    List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game);
+    default List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type,
+            Game game) {
+        List<MultiAmountMessage> constraints = messages.stream().map(s -> new MultiAmountMessage(s, 0, max))
+                .collect(Collectors.toList());
+
+        return getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(outcome, constraints, min, max, type, game);
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * Player distributes amount among multiple options
+     *
+     * @param outcome  AI hint
+     * @param messages List of options to distribute amount among. Each option has a constraint on the min, max chosen for it
+     * @param totalMin Total minimum amount to be distributed
+     * @param totalMax Total amount to be distributed
+     * @param type     MultiAmountType enum to set dialog options such as title and header
+     * @param game     Game
+     * @return List of integers with size equal to messages.size().  The sum of the integers is equal to max.
+     */
+    List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages, int min,
+            int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game);
 
     void sideboard(Match match, Deck deck);
 

Mage/src/main/java/mage/players/StubPlayer.java

@@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ import mage.target.Target;
 import mage.target.TargetAmount;
 import mage.target.TargetCard;
 import mage.target.TargetPlayer;
+import mage.util.MultiAmountMessage;
 
 import java.io.Serializable;
 import java.util.ArrayList;
@@ -207,7 +208,8 @@ public class StubPlayer extends PlayerImpl implements Player {
     }
 
     @Override
-    public List<Integer> getMultiAmount(Outcome outcome, List<String> messages, int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
+    public List<Integer> getMultiAmountWithIndividualConstraints(Outcome outcome, List<MultiAmountMessage> messages,
+            int min, int max, MultiAmountType type, Game game) {
         return null;
     }
 

Mage/src/main/java/mage/util/MultiAmountMessage.java

@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+package mage.util;
+
+import java.io.Serializable;
+
+// Author: alexander-novo
+// A helper class for facilitating the multi-choose dialog
+public class MultiAmountMessage implements Serializable {
+    public String message;
+    public int min;
+    public int max;
+
+    public MultiAmountMessage(String message, int min, int max) {
+        this.message = message;
+        this.min = min;
+        this.max = max;
+    }
+}